REG NASA-LLIS-2051-2009 Lessons Learned CAD environment could not handle drawing and model size on the project ARES 1-X Upper Stage Simulator (USS).pdf

1、Lessons Learned Entry: 2051Lesson Info:a71 Lesson Number: 2051a71 Lesson Date: 2009-4-30a71 Submitting Organization: GRCa71 Submitted by: Carl Blasera71 POC Email: carl.m.blasernasa.govSubject: CAD environment could not handle drawing and model size on the project ARES 1-X Upper Stage Simulator (USS

2、) Abstract: Transferring into 2 D assembly drawings became difficult to complete in a timely fashion. Engineering change orders would stack up thus resulting in fragmented as-built configuration. Many drawings did not incorporate the change orders.Description of Driving Event: Pro-Engineer CAD softw

3、are and Windchill configuration management software were used in combination to create and manage CAD files. We migrated to Windchill half way through the project and later found that Windchill uses a large amount of computer memory to track files. The design team also lacked large assembly file man

4、agement skills. We needed more powerful computers; however, only some of the employees received them in a timely manner. On ARES 1-X USS, model and drawing file sizes grew very fast after the conceptual stage passed. Designers struggled to complete assembly drawings. Computer power and file manageme

5、nt techniques were lagging as the schedule pressure continued. Much time was spent waiting for frozen computers to update so the next change could be made. Internal CAD support was insufficient to address our productivity issues. Additional CAD support was not funded.Lesson(s) Learned: The design an

6、d drawing team needs adequate training and expert consultation to deal with problems that arise. While the project was successfully completed, the CAD environment caused undue stress, loss of productivity and low morale. The problem was addressed by learning new techniques the hard Provided by IHSNo

7、t for ResaleNo reproduction or networking permitted without license from IHS-,-,-way and by hiring more temporary designers.Recommendation(s): Capabilities of all Centers CAD environments must be understood prior to securing new work. The CAD environment setup, hardware, software and network should

8、be thoroughly evaluated to ensure capability to handle very large file sizes such as assembly drawings necessary for future flight projects. This assessment should be conducted by utilizing large system level drawings typical of the new work that NASA is currently involved in, especially Constellati

9、on. In addition, the designers need to be involved in the process of setting up the CAD environment, including requirements such as: knowledgeable parties, expertise, infrastructure, equipment, softwareetc. This assessment can be used as a guide to evaluate the current CAD environment capability to

10、meet future work needs. For example, 060213MFA000 is a USS top level drawing that exemplifies the difficulties GRC had with large drawings. This is primarily a system level drawing, typical of future work, such as ARES V. It is recommended that this drawing be used to assess the current GRC CAD envi

11、ronment.Evidence of Recurrence Control Effectiveness: N/ADocuments Related to Lesson: N/AMission Directorate(s): a71 Exploration SystemsAdditional Key Phrase(s): a71 0a71 0a71 1.Simulators and Training Systemsa71 0.Engineering design and project processes and standardsa71 0.Configuration control and

12、 data managementa71 1.“a71 0.“a71 0.Computer-Aided Design/Manufacturing/Engineeringa71 0.“Additional Info: Provided by IHSNot for ResaleNo reproduction or networking permitted without license from IHS-,-,-a71 Project: ARES 1-X Upper Stage SimulatorApproval Info: a71 Approval Date: 2009-12-10a71 Approval Name: mbella71 Approval Organization: HQProvided by IHSNot for ResaleNo reproduction or networking permitted without license from IHS-,-,-