ANSI ASTM E2536 REV A-2015 Standard Guide for Assessment of Measurement Uncertainty in Fire Tests.pdf

1、Designation: E2536 15a An American National StandardStandard Guide forAssessment of Measurement Uncertainty in Fire Tests1This standard is issued under the fixed designation E2536; the number immediately following the designation indicates the year oforiginal adoption or, in the case of revision, th

2、e year of last revision. A number in parentheses indicates the year of last reapproval. Asuperscript epsilon () indicates an editorial change since the last revision or reapproval.INTRODUCTIONThe objective of a measurement is to determine the value of the measurand, that is, the physicalquantity tha

3、t needs to be measured. Every measurement is subject to error, no matter how carefullyit is conducted. The (absolute) error of a measurement is defined in Eq 1.All terms in Eq 1 have the units of the physical quantity that is measured. This equation cannot beused to determine the error of a measurem

4、ent because the true value is unknown, otherwise ameasurement would not be needed. In fact, the true value of a measurand is unknowable because itcannot be measured without error. However, it is possible to estimate, with some confidence, theexpected limits of error. This estimate is referred to as

5、the uncertainty of the measurement andprovides a quantitative indication of its quality.Errors of measurement have two components, a random component and a systematic component.The former is due to a number of sources that affect a measurement in a random and uncontrolledmanner. Random errors cannot

6、 be eliminated, but their effect on uncertainty is reduced by increasingthe number of repeat measurements and by applying a statistical analysis to the results. Systematicerrors remain unchanged when a measurement is repeated under the same conditions. Their effect onuncertainty cannot be completely

7、 eliminated either, but is reduced by applying corrections to accountfor the error contribution due to recognized systematic effects. The residual systematic error isunknown and shall be treated as a random error for the purpose of this standard.General principles for evaluating and reporting measur

8、ement uncertainties are described in theGuide on Uncertainty of Measurements (GUM). Application of the GUM to fire test data presentssome unique challenges. This standard shows how these challenges can be overcome. An example toillustrate application of the guidelines provided in this standard can b

9、e found in Appendix X1.y 2 Y (1)where: = measurement error;y = measured value of the measurand; andY = true value of the measurand.1. Scope1.1 This guide covers the evaluation and expression ofuncertainty of measurements of fire test methods developedand maintained byASTM International, based on the

10、 approachpresented in the GUM. The use in this process of precision dataobtained from a round robin is also discussed.1.2 The guidelines presented in this standard can also beapplied to evaluate and express the uncertainty associated withfire test results. However, it may not be possible to quantify

11、 theuncertainty of fire test results if some sources of uncertaintycannot be accounted for. This problem is discussed in moredetail in Appendix X2.1.3 Application of this guide is limited to tests that providequantitative results in engineering units. This includes, for1This guide is under the juris

12、diction ofASTM Committee E05 on Fire Standardsand is the direct responsibility of Subcommittee E05.31 on Terminology andServices / Functions.Current edition approved Oct. 1, 2015. Published November 2015. Originallyapproved in 2006. Last previous edition approved in 2015 as E2536-15. DOI:10.1520/E25

13、36-15A.Copyright ASTM International, 100 Barr Harbor Drive, PO Box C700, West Conshohocken, PA 19428-2959. United States1example, methods for measuring the heat release rate ofburning specimens based on oxygen consumption calorimetry,such as Test Method E1354.1.4 This guide does not apply to tests t

14、hat provide results inthe form of indices or binary results (for example, pass/fail).For example, the uncertainty of the Flame Spread Indexobtained according to Test Method E84 cannot be determined.1.5 In some cases additional guidance is required to supple-ment this standard. For example, the expre

15、ssion of uncertaintyof heat release rate measurements at low levels requiresadditional guidance and uncertainties associated with samplingare not explicitly addressed.1.6 This fire standard cannot be used to provide quantitativemeasures.1.7 The values stated in SI units are to be regarded asstandard

16、. No other units of measurement are included in thisstandard.2. Referenced Documents2.1 ASTM Standards:2E84 Test Method for Surface Burning Characteristics ofBuilding MaterialsE119 Test Methods for Fire Tests of Building Constructionand MaterialsE176 Terminology of Fire StandardsE230 Specification a

17、nd Temperature-Electromotive Force(EMF) Tables for Standardized ThermocouplesE691 Practice for Conducting an Interlaboratory Study toDetermine the Precision of a Test MethodE1354 Test Method for Heat and Visible Smoke ReleaseRates for Materials and Products Using an Oxygen Con-sumption Calorimeter2.

18、2 ISO Standards:3ISO/IEC 17025 General requirements for the competence oftesting and calibration laboratoriesGUM Guide to the expression of uncertainty in measure-ment2.3 CEN Standard:4EN 13823 Reaction to fire tests for building products Building products excluding floorings exposed to thethermal a

19、ttack by a single burning item3. Terminology3.1 Definitions: For definitions of terms used in this guideand associated with fire issues, refer to the terminologycontained in Terminology E176. For definitions of terms usedin this guide and associated with precision issues, refer to theterminology con

20、tained in Practice E691.3.2 Definitions of Terms Specific to This Standard:3.2.1 accuracy of measurement, ncloseness of the agree-ment between the result of a measurement and the true value ofthe measurand.3.2.2 combined standard uncertainty, nstandard uncer-tainty of the result of a measurement whe

21、n that result isobtained from the values of a number of other quantities, equalto the positive square root of a sum of terms, the terms beingthe variances or covariances of these other quantities weightedaccording to how the measurement result varies with changesin these quantities.3.2.3 coverage fa

22、ctor, nnumerical factor used as a multi-plier of the combined standard uncertainty in order to obtain anexpanded uncertainty.3.2.4 error (of measurement), nresult of a measurementminus the true value of the measurand; error consists of twocomponents: random error and systematic error.3.2.5 expanded

23、uncertainty, nquantity defining an intervalabout the result of a measurement that may be expected toencompass a large fraction of the distribution of values thatcould reasonably be attributed to the measurand.3.2.6 measurand, nquantity subject to measurement.3.2.7 precision, nvariability of test res

24、ult measurementsaround reported test result value.3.2.8 random error, nresult of a measurement minus themean that would result from an infinite number of measure-ments of the same measurand carried out under repeatabilityconditions.3.2.9 repeatability (of results of measurements),ncloseness of the a

25、greement between the results of succes-sive independent measurements of the same measurand carriedout under repeatability conditions.3.2.10 repeatability conditions, non identical test materialusing the same measurement procedure, observer(s), andmeasuring instrument(s) and performed in the same lab

26、oratoryduring a short period of time.3.2.11 reproducibility (of results of measurements), ncloseness of the agreement between the results of measure-ments of the same measurand carried out under reproducibilityconditions.3.2.12 reproducibility conditions, non identical test mate-rial using the same

27、measurement procedure, but differentobserver(s) and measuring instrument(s) in different laborato-ries performed during a short period of time.3.2.13 standard deviation, na quantity characterizing thedispersion of the results of a series of measurements of thesame measurand; the standard deviation i

28、s proportional to thesquare root of the sum of the squared deviations of themeasured values from the mean of all measurements.3.2.14 standard uncertainty, nuncertainty of the result ofa measurement expressed as a standard deviation.3.2.15 systematic error (or bias), nmean that would resultfrom an in

29、finite number of measurements of the same mea-surand carried out under repeatability conditions minus the truevalue of the measurand.2For referenced ASTM standards, visit the ASTM website, www.astm.org, orcontact ASTM Customer Service at serviceastm.org. For Annual Book of ASTMStandards volume infor

30、mation, refer to the standards Document Summary page onthe ASTM website.3Available from International Organization for Standardization, P.O. Box 56,CH-1211, Geneva 20, Switzerland.4Available from European Committee for Standardization (CEN), AvenueMarnix 17, B-1000, Brussels, Belgium, http:/www.cen.

31、eu.E2536 15a23.2.16 type A evaluation (of uncertainty), nmethod ofevaluation of uncertainty by the statistical analysis of series ofobservations.3.2.17 type B evaluation (of uncertainty), nmethod ofevaluation of uncertainty by means other than the statisticalanalysis of series of observations.3.2.18

32、 uncertainty of measurement, nparameter, associ-ated with the result of a measurement, that characterizes thedispersion of the values that could reasonably be attributed tothe measurand.4. Summary of Guide4.1 This guide provides concepts and calculation methods toassess the uncertainty of measuremen

33、ts obtained from firetests.4.2 Appendix X1 of this guide contains an example toillustrate application of this guide by assessing the uncertaintyof heat release rate measured in the Cone Calorimeter (TestMethod E1354).5. Significance and Use5.1 Users of fire test data often need a quantitative indica

34、-tion of the quality of the data presented in a test report. Thisquantitative indication is referred to as the “measurementuncertainty”. There are two primary reasons for estimating theuncertainty of fire test results.5.1.1 ISO/IEC 17025 requires that competent testing andcalibration laboratories in

35、clude uncertainty estimates for theresults that are presented in a report.5.1.2 Fire safety engineers need to know the quality of theinput data used in an analysis to determine the uncertainty ofthe outcome of the analysis.6. Evaluating Standard Uncertainty6.1 A quantitative result of a fire test Y

36、is generally notobtained from a direct measurement, but is determined as afunction f from N input quantities X1, , XN:Y 5 f X1,X2,XN! (2)where:Y = measurand;f = functional relationship between the measurand and theinput quantities; andXi= input quantities (i =1 N).6.1.1 The input quantities are cate

37、gorized as:6.1.1.1 quantities whose values and uncertainties are di-rectly determined from single observation, repeated observa-tion or judgment based on experience, or6.1.1.2 quantities whose values and uncertainties arebrought into the measurement from external sources such asreference data obtain

38、ed from handbooks.6.1.2 An estimate of the output, y, is obtained from Eq 2using input estimates x1, x2, , xNfor the values of the N inputquantities:y 5 f x1,x2, xN! (3)Substituting Eq 2 and 3 into Eq 1 leads to:y 5 Y1 5 Y111211N(4)where:1= contribution to the total measurement error from theerror a

39、ssociated with xi.6.2 A possible approach to determine the uncertainty of yinvolves a large number (n) of repeat measurements. The meanvalue of the resulting distribution y! is the best estimate of themeasurand. The experimental standard deviation of the mean isthe best estimate of the standard unce

40、rtainty of y, denoted byu(y):uy!=s2y! 5 s2y!n5!(k51nyk2 y!2nn 2 1!(5)where:u = standard uncertainty,s = experimental standard deviation,n = number of observations;yk=kthmeasured value, andy = mean of n measurements.The number of observations n shall be large enough toensure that y provides a reliabl

41、e estimate of the expectation yof the random variable y, and that s2y! provides a reliableestimate of the variance 2y!5y!/n. If the probability distri-bution of y is normal, then standard deviation of s y! relativeto y! is approximately 2(n-1)1/2. Thus, for n = 10 therelative uncertainty of s y! is

42、24 %t, while for n =50itis10%. Additional values are given in Table E.1 in annex E of theGUM.6.3 Unfortunately it is often not feasible or even possible toperform a sufficiently large number of repeat measurements. Inthose cases, the uncertainty of the measurement can bedetermined by combining the s

43、tandard uncertainties of theinput estimates. The standard uncertainty of an input estimatexiis obtained from the distribution of possible values of theinput quantity Xi. There are two types of evaluations dependingon how the distribution of possible values is obtained.6.3.1 Type A evaluation of stan

44、dard uncertaintyA type Aevaluation of standard uncertainty of xiis based on thefrequency distribution, which is estimated from a series of nrepeated observations xi,k(k = 1 n). The resulting equationis similar to Eq 5:uxi!=s2xi! 5 s2xi!n5!(k51nxi,k2 xi!2nn 2 1!(6)where:xi,k=kthmeasured value; andxi=

45、 mean of n measurements.6.3.2 Type B evaluation of standard uncertainty:6.3.2.1 A type B evaluation of standard uncertainty of xiisnot based on repeated measurements but on an a priorifrequency distribution. In this case the uncertainty is deter-mined from previous measurements data, experience or g

46、eneralknowledge, manufacturers specifications, data provided inE2536 15a3calibration certificates, uncertainties assigned to reference datataken from handbooks, etc.6.3.2.2 If the quoted uncertainty from a manufacturerspecification, handbook or other source is stated to be aparticular multiple of a

47、standard deviation, the standard uncer-tainty uc(xi) is simply the quoted value divided by the multi-plier. For example, the quoted uncertainty is often at the 95 %level of confidence. Assuming a normal distribution thiscorresponds to a multiplier of two, that is, the standarduncertainty is half the

48、 quoted value.6.3.2.3 Often the uncertainty is expressed in the form ofupper and lower limits. Usually there is no specific knowledgeabout the possible values of Xiwithin the interval and one canonly assume that it is equally probable for Xito lie anywhere init. Fig. 1 shows the most common example

49、where the corre-sponding rectangular distribution is symmetric with respect toits best estimate xi. The standard uncertainty in this case isgiven by:uxi! 5Xi=3(7)where:Xi= half-width of the interval.If some information is known about the distribution of thepossible values of Xiwithin the interval, that knowledge is usedto better estimate the standard deviation.6.3.3 Accounting for multiple sources of errorThe uncer-tainty of an input quantity is sometimes due to multiple sourceserror. In this ca