ANSI INCITS423.1-2008 Information technology - Conformance Testing Methodology Standard for Biometric Data Interchange Format Standards - Part 1 Generalized Conformance Testing Met.pdf

1、American National StandardDeveloped byfor Information Technology Conformance TestingMethodology Standard forBiometric Data InterchangeFormat Standards Part 1: GeneralizedConformance Testing MethodologyANSI INCITS 423.1-2008ANSIINCITS 423.1-2008Copyright American National Standards Institute Provided

2、 by IHS under license with ANSI Not for ResaleNo reproduction or networking permitted without license from IHS-,-,-Copyright American National Standards Institute Provided by IHS under license with ANSI Not for ResaleNo reproduction or networking permitted without license from IHS-,-,-ANSIINCITS 423

3、.1-2008American National Standardfor Information Technology Conformance TestingMethodology Standard forBiometric Data InterchangeFormat Standards Part 1: Generalized ConformanceTesting MethodologySecretariatInformation Technology Industry CouncilApproved January 23, 2008American National Standards I

4、nstitute, Inc.Copyright American National Standards Institute Provided by IHS under license with ANSI Not for ResaleNo reproduction or networking permitted without license from IHS-,-,-Approval of an American National Standard requires review by ANSI that therequirements for due process, consensus,

5、and other criteria for approval havebeen met by the standards developer.Consensus is established when, in the judgement of the ANSI Board ofStandards Review, substantial agreement has been reached by directly andmaterially affected interests. Substantial agreement means much more thana simple majori

6、ty, but not necessarily unanimity. Consensus requires that allviews and objections be considered, and that a concerted effort be madetowards their resolution.The use of American National Standards is completely voluntary; theirexistence does not in any respect preclude anyone, whether he has approve

7、dthe standards or not, from manufacturing, marketing, purchasing, or usingproducts, processes, or procedures not conforming to the standards.The American National Standards Institute does not develop standards andwill in no circumstances give an interpretation of any American NationalStandard. Moreo

8、ver, no person shall have the right or authority to issue aninterpretation of an American National Standard in the name of the AmericanNational Standards Institute. Requests for interpretations should beaddressed to the secretariat or sponsor whose name appears on the titlepage of this standard.CAUT

9、ION NOTICE: This American National Standard may be revised orwithdrawn at any time. The procedures of the American National StandardsInstitute require that action be taken periodically to reaffirm, revise, orwithdraw this standard. Purchasers of American National Standards mayreceive current informa

10、tion on all standards by calling or writing the AmericanNational Standards Institute.American National StandardPublished byAmerican National Standards Institute, Inc.25 West 43rd Street, New York, NY 10036Copyright 2008 by Information Technology Industry Council (ITI)All rights reserved.No part of t

11、his publication may be reproduced in anyform, in an electronic retrieval system or otherwise,without prior written permission of ITI, 1250 Eye Street NW, Washington, DC 20005. Printed in the United States of AmericaCAUTION: The developers of this standard have requested that holders of patents that

12、may berequired for the implementation of the standard disclose such patents to the publisher. However,neither the developers nor the publisher have undertaken a patent search in order to identifywhich, if any, patents may apply to this standard. As of the date of publication of this standardand foll

13、owing calls for the identification of patents that may be required for the implementation ofthe standard, no such claims have been made. No further patent search is conducted by the de-veloper or publisher in respect to any standard it processes. No representation is made or impliedthat licenses are

14、 not required to avoid infringement in the use of this standard.Copyright American National Standards Institute Provided by IHS under license with ANSI Not for ResaleNo reproduction or networking permitted without license from IHS-,-,-iContentsPageForeword iiIntroduction vii0 Scope. 11 Conformance .

15、 22 Normative References . 23 Terms and Definitions 34 Conformance Testing Levels . 44.1 General Considerations . 44.2 Conformance Testing Types 54.3 Conformance Testing Hierarchy 54.4 Conformance Testing Level. 64.4.1 Level 1 - Data Format Conformance 64.4.2 Level 2 - Internal Consistency Checking

16、74.4.3 Level 3 - Content Checking 74.5 Data Sets . 84.6 Test Reports 95 Assertion Elements for Level 1 and 2 Testing . 105.1 Introduction 105.2 Assertion Element Descriptions. 115.2.1 Field Names. 115.2.2 Operators. 115.2.2.1 Equal (EQ) . 115.2.2.2 Not-Equal (NEQ) 115.2.2.3 Greater Than or Equal (GT

17、E) 125.2.2.4 Less Than or Equal (LTE) 125.2.2.5 Greater Than (GT) . 125.2.2.6 Less Than (LT). 125.2.2.7 Incremental (INC). 125.2.2.8 Calculation (C) . 125.2.3 Operands . 125.2.3.1 Field Name 125.2.3.2 Read 125.2.3.3 Bytes Read 135.2.3.4 Total Bytes Read . 135.2.3.5 Bytes Expected 135.2.3.6 Total Byt

18、es Expected. 135.2.4 Other Assertion Elements 135.2.4.1 Conditional. 135.2.4.2 References. 13AnnexA Bibliography . 14Copyright American National Standards Institute Provided by IHS under license with ANSI Not for ResaleNo reproduction or networking permitted without license from IHS-,-,-iiForeword (

19、This foreword is not part of American National Standard ANSI INCITS 423.1-2008.)This multipart standard describes a common set of methodologies and procedures tobe followed for conducting conformance testing for a series of INCITS biometric datainterchange format base standards. The first part, cont

20、ained in this document, de-scribes the different types of conformance testing and provides guidelines on con-ducting the tests and reporting the results. It also provides a set of common elementsfor defining test assertions. Each of the subsequent parts contains specific instruc-tions relevant to a

21、single data interchange format base standard, including the rele-vant tests and assertions defined using the common assertion elements from thispart.The INCITS 423 multipart standard currently comprises the following parts under thegeneral title “Conformance Testing Methodology Standard for Biometri

22、c Data Inter-change Format Standards“:Part 1: Generalized Conformance Testing MethodologyPart 2: Conformance Testing Methodology for INCITS 378-2004, Finger Mi-nutiae Format for Data InterchangePart 3: Conformance Testing Methodology for INCITS 377-2004, Finger Pat-tern Data Interchange FormatPart 4

23、: Conformance Testing Methodology for INCITS 381, Finger Image-Based Data Interchange FormatPart 5: Conformance Testing Methodology for INCITS 385, Face Recogni-tion Format for Data InterchangePart 6: Conformance Testing Methodology for INCITS 379, Iris Image Inter-change FormatRequests for interpre

24、tation, suggestions for improvement or addenda, or defect re-ports are welcome. They should be sent to InterNational Committee for InformationTechnology Standards (INCITS), ITI, 1250 Eye Street, NW, Suite 200, Washington,DC 20005.This standard was processed and approved for submittal to ANSI by INCI

25、TS. Com-mittee approval of this standard does not necessarily imply that all committee mem-bers voted for its approval. At the time it approved this standard, INCITS had thefollowing members:Karen Higginbottom, ChairJennifer Garner, SecretaryOrganization Represented Name of RepresentativeAdobe Syste

26、ms, Inc Leslie BixelSteve Ziles (Alt.)AIM Global, Inc. Dan MullenCharles Biss (Alt.)Apple Computer, Inc. David MichaelElectronic Industries Alliance Edward Mikoski, Jr.David Thompson (Alt.)EMC Corporation Gary RobinsonFarance, Inc Frank FaranceTimothy Schoechle (Alt.)GS1 US Frank SharkeyJames Chrono

27、wski (Alt.)Mary Wilson (Alt.)Copyright American National Standards Institute Provided by IHS under license with ANSI Not for ResaleNo reproduction or networking permitted without license from IHS-,-,-iiiOrganization Represented Name of RepresentativeHewlett-Packard Company .Karen HigginbottomSteve M

28、ills (Alt.)Scott Jameson (Alt.)IBM Corporation Ronald F. SillettiRobert Weir (Alt.)Sandy Block (Alt.)Richard Schwerdtfeger (Alt.)IEEE Judith GormanTerry DeCourcelle (Alt.)Bill Ash (Alt.)Jodi Haasz (Alt.)Bob Labelle (Alt.)Intel .Philip WennblomDave Thewlis (Alt.)Jesse Walker (Alt.)Grace Wei (Alt.)Lex

29、mark InternationalDon WrightDwight Lewis (Alt.)Paul Menard (Alt.)Microsoft CorporationJim HughesDon Stanwyck (Alt.)Isabelle Valet-Harper (Alt.)National Institute of Standards & Technology .Michael HoganElaine Barker (Alt.)Dan Benigni (Alt.)Fernando Podio (Alt.)Teresa Schwarzhoff (Alt.)Oracle Corpora

30、tionDonald R. DeutschJim Melton (Alt.)Tony DiCenzo (Alt.)Peter Lord (Alt.)Toshihiro Suzuki (Alt.)Sony Electronics, Inc.Ed BarrettJean Baronas (Alt.)US Department of Defense .Jerry SmithDennis Devera (Alt.)Dave Brown (Alt.)Leonard Levine (Alt.)US Department of Homeland Security Peter ShebellJohn Neum

31、ann (Alt.)Copyright American National Standards Institute Provided by IHS under license with ANSI Not for ResaleNo reproduction or networking permitted without license from IHS-,-,-Technical Committee M1, Biometrics, which reviewed this standard, had the follow-ing members:Fernando Podio, ChairWayne

32、 Kyle, Vice-ChairOrganization Represented Name of Representative3M/AiT Yuan Jia Roger Larson (Alt.)A4 Vision Artem YukhinPavel Morozov (Alt.)ATMEL Jean-Francois MainguetDavid Richard (Alt.)Authenti-Corp . Valorie Valencia Aware, Inc. David Benini Rob Mungovan (Alt.)BearingPoint. Rish PathakRon Sutto

33、n (Alt.)Biocom Wayne KyleThe Biometric Foundation Paul CollierFred Herr (Alt.)Bioscrypt, Inc Colin Soutar Omid Jahromi (Alt.)Booz Allen and Hamilton, Inc. Donald WaymireKeith Andreano (Alt.)Cogent Systems . Anne WangXian Tang (Alt.)Computer Sciences Corporation (CSC) . Rick LazarickDaniel Munyan (Al

34、t.)Cross Match Technologies, Inc. . Greg CannonDaon. Cathy TiltonMathew Swayze (Alt.)EDS Jeff StephensJeffery Poulson (Alt.)Fujitsu Laboratories Johnathan AgreGerald Byrnes (Alt.)Geometrix. Thomas MaurerDavid West (Alt.)International Biometric Group LLC . Michael ThiemePhil Youn (Alt.)ID Technology

35、Partners, Inc. Mark Jerde Richard Chang (Alt.)Identix Corporation . Kirsten Rudolph NobelPaul Griffin (Alt.)Erik Bowman (Alt.)L1 Identity Solutions . Tim BrownUdo Mahlmeister (Alt.)Mitretek Systems Donald DAmato Harold Korves (Alt.)Motorola, Inc. Artour KaraguiozianGuy Cardwell (Alt.)NBSP Gerald O.

36、WilliamsJohn Campbell (Alt.)NIST . Fernando Podio Michael Hogan (Alt.)Michael McCabe (Alt.)OSS Nokalva Alessandro TrigliaPaul Thorpe (Alt.)Precise Biometrics Ken GregoryKrister Walfridsson (Alt.)Purdue University . Stephen Elliott Matt Young (Alt.)Eric Kukula (Alt.)Recognition Systems Samir TamerRic

37、k White (Alt.)Copyright American National Standards Institute Provided by IHS under license with ANSI Not for ResaleNo reproduction or networking permitted without license from IHS-,-,-vOrganization Represented Name of RepresentativeRetica Systems .David MullerYasonari Tosa (Alt.)Sagem Morpho, Inc.C

38、reed Jones Underwriters Laboratories.Louis ChavezDave Mills (Alt.)United States Dept. of Defense - BMO/BFC .Ramy GuirguisGregory Zektser (Alt.)Dale Hapeman (Alt.)United States Dept. of Homeland SecurityBradford WingJohn Neumann (Alt.)Steve Jonkers (Alt.)United States Dept. of StateBarry Kefauver Joh

39、n Akins (Alt.)UPEK Mike ChaudoinWest Virginia University LaRue Williams Arun Ross (Alt.)Copyright American National Standards Institute Provided by IHS under license with ANSI Not for ResaleNo reproduction or networking permitted without license from IHS-,-,-viTask Group M1.3 on Biometric Data Inter

40、change Formats, which developed thisstandard, had the following members:Creed Jones, ChairJames Cambier Vice-ChairGreg Cannon, SecretaryOrganization Represented Name of Representative3M Co . Yuan JiaA4 Vision, Inc Pavel MorozovBruce Batemann (Alt.)Anametrics Paul SchueppAssoy Abbloy Michael DavisAwa

41、re, Inc. David BeniniBAI Mike ChaudoinBearingPoint . Amarish PathakBioPassword. David FriantSeshadri Mani (Alt.)Bioscrypt, Inc. . Colin SoutarBooz Allen Hamilton . Chris CrooksCogent Systems, Inc. Anne WangXian Tang (Alt.)Cross Match Technologies, Inc. . Greg CannonCSC Rick LazarickDaon . Connor Whi

42、teMatt Swayze (Alt.)Fujitsu . John AgreGeometrix . Thomas MaurerID Tech Partners. Mark JerdeIdentix Corporation . Kirsten Rudolph NobelPaul Griffin (Alt.)L1 Kirsten NobleMitretek Systems Donald DAmatoMotorola Artour KaraguiozianNBSP John CampbellNIST Michael McCabeMichael Hogan (Alt.)OSS Nokalva Ale

43、ssandro TrigliaPurdue Shimon ModiStephen Elliot (Alt.)Recognition Systems, Inc. Samir TamerRetica Systems. David MullerNick Accomando (Alt.)Transaction Security, Inc. . Rod BeatsonUnited States Army - BTF. Robert YenGregory Zekster (Alt.)United States Dept. of Homeland Security . John Mayer-SplainVi

44、ola Lee (Alt.)United States Dept. of State . Barry KefauverUPEK John HochsteinCopyright American National Standards Institute Provided by IHS under license with ANSI Not for ResaleNo reproduction or networking permitted without license from IHS-,-,-viiIntroductionRecently, INCITS M1 has developed a

45、number of biometric data interchange formatstandards for different biometric modalities or technologies. Other standards for addi-tional modalities or technologies are expected to be developed in the future. End us-ers of biometric systems desire to use these standards to ensure that components ofth

46、e biometric system can be substituted with other components from different ven-dors with a minimum of effort, and also to ensure that biometric data produced byone system can be used by another system. In order to achieve this, it is critical thatsystems claiming conformance to the system actually a

47、re conformant, and thus thereis a need for conformance testing methodology standards for each of the biometricdata interchange formats, in order to provide a reasonable degree of assurance thata conformance claim has validity. In fact, no test can be absolutely comprehensiveand prove that a given sy

48、stem is conformant under all possible circumstances, espe-cially when there are optional components of the standard. A well-designed conform-ance test can, however, test all of the most likely sources of problems and ensurethat the system under test conforms under a reasonable set of circumstances, givingassurance, but not a guarantee, of conformance.There are many different types of conformance testing that may be appropriate forthe various biometric data interchange format standards. Some of these tests arehighly specific to each data interchange format but some of them have many com-mon e