1、Integrated Care: A National Perspective,Collaborative Family Healthcare Association California Summit October 22, 2009 San Diego, CA Barbara Mauer, MSW, CMC MCPP Healthcare Consulting National Council Consulting Team,Where Should Care Be Delivered? The National Council Four Quadrant Integration Mode
2、l,Organize our understanding of the many differing approachesthere is no single method of integration Think about the needs of the population and appropriate targeting of services Clarify the respective roles of PCP and MH/SU providers, depending on the needs of the person being served Identify the
3、system tools and clinician skill and knowledge sets needed and how they vary by subpopulation Population based for system planning, services should be person-centered,Where Should Care Be Delivered? Stepped Care,There is always a boundary between primary care and specialty care There will always be
4、tradeoffs between the benefits of specialty expertise and of integration Stepped care is a clinical approach to assure that the need for a changing level of care is addressed appropriately for each personIMPACT research demonstrates the effectiveness of a stepped care model and is the basis for the
5、National Council Collaborative Care Project We need to implement this model bi-directionallyto identify people in primary care with MH/SU conditions and serve them there unless they need specialty care, and to identify people in MH/SU care that need basic primary care and step them to a full scope m
6、edical home for more complex carethe Four Quadrant model has been revised to reflect this thinking,Focus: Quadrants I and III,Model for Improving Primary Care,AHRQ: The Research,Quantitative and qualitative analysis of 33 trials that examined the impact of integrating MH specialists into primary car
7、e Studies tended to show positive results for symptom severity, treatment response and remission when compared to usual care Wide variation in levels of provider integration and integrated processes of care IMPACT has strongest results for adults and older adults; limited studies exist for children
8、More work is needed on understanding what elements of integration are vital to producing desired goals“research aimed at efficiently matching clinical and organizational processes and resources to different levels of care for varying levels of severity, and patients stratified by risk and complexity
9、, would build on theIMPACT trials and Intermountain Healthcares examples”,Core Components of IMPACT Collaborative Care Program,Doubles Effectiveness of Care for Depression,%,Participating Organizations,50 % or greater improvement in depression at 12 months,Unutzer et al, Psych Clin NA 2004,Lower Lon
10、g-term (4 Yr) Healthcare Costs,Substance Use Interventions in Primary Care,Center for Substance Abuse Treatment has sponsored Screening and Brief Intervention (SBI) programs in 17 states Based on more than 30 controlled clinical trials that demonstrated the clinical efficacy and effectiveness of SBI
11、 Screening and brief interventions for more than 424,000 people across inpatient, emergency department, primary and specialty care settings, including CHCs Newly established series of Current Procedural Terminology (CPT) SBI codes provide a vehicle for billing SBI services (99408 and 99409) http:/sb
12、irt.samhsa.gov/about.htm,The Person-Centered Healthcare Home: Q I and III,Incorporate the lessons of the IMPACT model, explicitly building into the medical home model the care manager/ behavioral health consultant and consulting psychiatrist functions that have proven effective in the IMPACT model D
13、IAMOND project in MNmonthly case rate payments for covering these components in primary care practices, all major payors participating All healthcare is localworking out the details of who does what, for what levels of MH/SU services (Intermountain model), has to engage local partnerships,Focus: Qua
14、drants II and IV,Morbidity and Mortality in People with Serious Mental Illness,Persons with serious mental illness (SMI) are dying 25 years earlier than the general population While suicide and injury account for about 30-40% of excess mortality, 60% of premature deaths in persons with schizophrenia
15、 are due to medical conditions such as cardiovascular, pulmonary and infectious diseases (NASMHPD, 2006) OR state study found that those with co-occurring MH/SU disorders were at greatest risk,Massachusetts Study: Deaths from Heart Disease by Age Group/DMH Enrollees with SMI Compared to Massachusett
16、s 1998-2000,3.5 RR,4.9RR,2.2RR,1.5RR,Maine Study: Comparison of Health Disorders Between SMI & Non-SMI Groups,Harris et al. Diabetes Care. 1998; 21:518. Mukherjee et al. Compr Psychiatry. 1996; 37(1):68-73.,Schizophrenic:,General:,50-59 y,60-74 y,75+ y,Percent of population,Prevalence of Diagnosed D
17、iabetes in General Population Versus Schizophrenic Population,Team-Based Models of Care: Integrated Care Clinic,A medical clinic was established to manage routine medical problems of patients with SMI at a VA Nurse practitioner provided the bulk of medical services; a care manager provided patient e
18、ducation and referrals to mental health and medical specialists Study randomized 120 veterans to either the integrated care clinic or usual care, followed for one year Access: Significantly increased the rates and number of visits to medical providers, reduced likelihood of ER use Quality: Significa
19、ntly improved quality of most routine preventive services (15/17) Outcomes: Significantly improved scores on SF-36 Health Related Quality of Life Costs: Program cost-neutral from a VA perspective (primary care costs offset by reduction in inpatient costs),1. Druss BG, et al. Arch Gen Psychiatry. 200
20、1;58(9):861-868.,Other Promising Approaches,Nurse Heath Care Case Managermonitoring, facilitation, and coordination of primary/preventative health care Health education activities, including diabetes groups, nutrition and diet, physical activity, agreements with local health clubs, personal trainers
21、 Researched disease management group and educational materials (e.g. Lorig) for population with SMI, with peers trained as health educators CA Frequent Utilizers of Health Servicescare management reductions in ED utilization (by 60% in year two) Supported housing models that include on-site healthca
22、re capacity (WA DESCTotal cost offsets for Housing First participants relative to controls averaged $2449 per person per month after accounting for housing program costs),Measurement of Health Status for People with SMI (NASMHPD 2008),Standard set of health indicators that will be gathered and used
23、for the clinical care of each person served, as well as aggregated to provide population health data Piloted in 2009 in NY state Individual agencies piloting as well,MH Providers Clinical Responsibility and Accountability (National Council, 2008),If MH services include prescribing psychotropic medic
24、ations, there are a set of accountabilities related to the whole health of the person: Assure regular screening and tracking at the time of psychiatric visits for all consumers receiving psychotropic medications Check glucose and lipid levels, blood pressure and weight/BMI Record and track changes,
25、response to treatment and use the information to adjust treatment accordingly The individual and family history, baseline and longitudinal monitoring as recommended by the ADA/APA should be the standard of practice Identify the current PCP for each individual, and when none exists, assist the indivi
26、dual in finding a PCP and accessing care Establish specific methods for communication and treatment coordination with PCPs and assure that timely information is shared in both directions,The Person-Centered Healthcare Home for People with SMI,See Behavioral Health/Primary Care Integration and The Pe
27、rson-Centered Healthcare Home (National Council) For BH providers envisioning a future role as person-centered healthcare homes, there are two pathways to follow Providers who want to become full scope person-centered healthcare homes for people with SMI should look to the Cherokee model and seek to
28、 become full scope providers of primary care services, for a broad community population as well as for those receiving BH services Providers who want to partner with full scope primary care organizations to create person-centered healthcare homes for individuals with SMI should organize a parallel t
29、o the IMPACT primary care model, with collaborative care, care management, a designated PCP consultant, outcome measurement, and stepped care for primary care needs in BH settings,Assure regular screening and registry tracking/outcome measurement at the time of psychiatric visits for all BH consumer
30、s receiving psychotropic medications Locate medical nurse practitioners/PCPs in BH clinicsprovide routine primary care services in the BH setting via staff out-stationed under the auspices of a full scope person-centered healthcare home BH organization hiring a nurse practitioner directly, without t
31、he backup of a skilled PCP and a full scope healthcare home cannot be described as providing a healthcare home, and is not a recommended pathway Identify a primary care supervising physician within the full scope healthcare home to provide consultation on complex health issues Assign nurse care mana
32、gers to support individuals with elevated levels of glucose, lipids, blood pressure, and/or weight/BMI Use evidence based practices developed to improve the health status of all individuals with chronic health conditions, adapting these practices for use in the BH system. Create wellness programs,Th
33、e Person-Centered Healthcare Home for People with SMI: Partnership,Making Integration Sustainable,Financial or structural integration does not assure clinical integration Clinical integration helps us focus on what consumers need Clinical integration requires financial and structural supports in ord
34、er to be successful Public sector financing is a major barrier to achieving clinical integration in most safety net settings,Financing Integrated Care,Medicaid MH carve-in has been infrequent and disappointing New Mexico carved in, its 2000 waiver renewal initially was denied (only 55% of BH premium
35、 going to services); then reinstated (requires that 85% of BH premium go to services) note that the three health plans with the carve in contracts hired MBHCOs to manage - a carve out inside of the carve in!. The New Mexico system has continued to be restructured. Tennessee carved in briefly, then c
36、arved out, recently carved into one regional plan, with “disappointing” results University of South Florida MH Institute studied state systems regarding services for children and youth, and concluded that carve outs were better than integrated contracts, covering a broader array of services with mor
37、e flexibility,Financing Integrated Care,State MH systems and behavioral health carve-outs, as currently constructed, are a barrier to implementation of integrated care Most state MH systems are underfunded to serve the population with most serious/severe needs Carve-outs are used in 23 of the 28 sta
38、tes with Medicaid managed mental healthcare plans (financing generally driven by a 10% penetration rate assumption, which doesnt cover needs of mild/moderate) Creates concern that the populations in Q II and IV will lose services and access if the inadequate funding gets stretched to populations in
39、Q I and III Documentation requirements (20 page enrollment packets) in public MH systems are unworkable for primary care settings,Financing Integrated Care,We need a new paradigmnone of the old models work for implementing bidirectional integrated care for the whole population Expanded coverage for
40、the uninsured will help in the safety net system (many state MH systems are virtually Medicaid only) MNfinancing the DIAMOND project out of the healthcare side (rather than the mental health side) believing that cost and quality improvements will be there WA General Assistance projectexplicit steppe
41、d care model that finances both Level 1 (primary care) and Level 2 (specialty) MH/SU benefits; dedicated financing for Levels 1 and 2; neither draw on dedicated mental health funding Washtenawglobal budget for Medicaid population; local consolidation of medical and behavioral health funding streams
42、Medical Homescase rate in addition to FFS, to cover prevention, care management of chronic medical conditions (why not build the BHC in PC and consulting psychiatrist into the case rate?) Start by developing principles for financing that stakeholders will support,Conclusions,What it takes to succeed
43、 at a primary care/behavioral health integration at the service delivery level assuming that the financing and regulatory barriers are addressed: Workflows: Studying each clinical workflow step is necessary to design future processes that promote clinical integration Clear Provider Responsibilities:
44、 New tasks (e.g., behavioral health screening in primary care and registry management) should be assigned to the appropriate staff Data is Clinical Information: Data collection related to clinical progress typically requires a change of culture in which data is used to inform clinical practice Regis
45、try Tracking: Registries are a baseline technology that must be in place; one cannot succeed at integration without registry software “It will always take longer than anticipated. The simpler one can make the process for providers of care, the more likely that process will be successful.” (Illinois site, National Council Collaborative),Primary Care,Behavioral Health,Behavioral Health Referrals,Physical Health Status,Collaborative Health Services,Contact Information,Barbara J. Mauer, MSW CMC 206-613-3339 www.TheNationalCouncil.org/ResourceCenter,
